18 Bay - Feedback

Beautiful veranda dining experience with excellent service and creative, healthy veggie-forward vegan tasting menu. When we called and said we were vegan, they...

We stumbled at this great place last night. When Adam, chef, heard that we were vegetarian/ vegan, he came to our table very excited about preparing something s...

Set menu. Eating is always delicious. High-end restaurant, it's about $125 per person. So we always go to a celebrity dinner there. highly recommended.

I ate before two weeks in 18 booked with my family. the food was delicious and served in a timely occasion. I would say the star of the show was the cacio e pep...

Overall no bad first experience on shelter island. and this restaurant has a lot to do including a nice (and chatty) host, perfect ambiente, a.

The food is fun , nicely prepared and tasty. BUT the floor manager (Jim I think I heard him say) knocked 2 stars off my experience with his forced, self aggrand...

Overall, not a bad first experience on Shelter Island. And this restaurant has a lot going for it, including a nice (and chatty) host, perfect ambiance, a loyal...

I'm not sure if it was just an off night, but the food at this restaurant did not live up to its rave reviews and we were thoroughly disappointed with our exper...

Chefs Elizabeth and Adam, along with front of house manager and sommelier Jimmy, are taking 18 Bay to new heights. In my opinion, just the appetizer plate alone...

I went to 18 Bay on a Saturday night with low expectations due to the over-hyped reviews on Yelp, its location off the beaten path, and the busy summer season....