The Olde Erie Pub - Middletown

Everything was AMAZING !!! Shrimp scampi, broiled lobster tail, steamed little neck clams, eggplant tower !! I was a wonderful lunch !! Thank you Maria and Linda. I brought my Mom for her belated Mother's Day lunch and she loved it !!!

Always a Great Time, decades of fantastic Italian Specialties. Generations of serving the community and catering to private events. Thank You JoJo, Linda, Maria and family...

This restaurant is truly a hidden gem. Every dining experience here is exceptional, with a warm, well-decorated family atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. I visited with my fiancé on February 17 to celebrate her birthday, and we ordered the chicken Marsala and chicken cordon bleu. The food was exquisite—delicious, succulent, and bursting with amazing flavors. The presentation was like a work of art. The portions are generous, which I really appreciate, as it means I can take leftovers home to enjoy the next day. A big shoutout to the chef! Please continue to be the culinary treasure you’ve been for years; I can’t wait for my next visit!

I recently dined at this restaurant with my fiancé, and we were thoroughly impressed. We ordered zucchini fries, cream of chicken soup, salad, stuffed shells, ribeye steak, and chicken cordon bleu, and every dish was delicious, fresh, and cooked to perfection. The portions were generous, and the staff was very attentive. This place has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants. I’ve recommended it to all my friends, praising the amazing food. I will definitely be returning soon!

The restaurant was quite busy, but we had to wait a considerable amount of time for our drinks. The food, however, was delicious and the portions were generous. Our waitress was very friendly; she engaged in conversation and joked with us, which made our experience enjoyable.