Rashida Sawyer Bakery - Ithaca

Finally, an unpretentious Ithaca business that seems authentically pleased when you stop in, instead of the who are you gaze and attitude which comes from so many places on the Commons. Hands down, the best Brownie that I have ever had. That alone is how I came to appreciate the over-all quality of the baked goods at this independent establishment. Cheesecake, also, knocks it out of the park!

Rashida Sawyer Bakery makes the most delicious cheesecake we've ever tasted. From the walnut crust to sour cherry topping, there is an incredible amount of attention in every detail. The ingredients and packaging are of the highest quality. Not only delicious, but a beautiful cake to look at as well.

I have utilized to this bakery a few times and twice I have not received the incorrect order! I received either the wrong flavor cake or wrong decorations.Furthermore, they didn’t even offer any compensation for their errors. Great product but horrible quality check. The customer service is lacking also.

Rashida Sawyer Bakery's cheesecakes are fantastic. Probably the best cheesecake I have ever had (even compared to cherished family recipes of our own)! We ordered one regular and one chocolate for a weekend with family and both were hits. The walnut crust of the regular one doesn't get soggy like cheesecake crusts from other bakeries in town, and the chocolate one wasn't too sweet, which I really appreciated. Further, the staff at the bakery were professional, friendly, and easy to coordinate with for our order. I highly recommend for any cheesecake-related celebratory (or non-celebratory) needs you may have.

Ordered piece of carrot cake, in the crowded case it was 4in x 4in and price was listed at $6, then they cut it in half! false ads in my book! they were nice enough to drink a fresh coffee. and carrot cake was very good, just not enough!