Smuggler's Wharf - Erie

It ended in a split decision. MY GF is a vegan and has tried their offerings four times and has yet to be impressed, although the fourth was more favorable than the first three times as I had a hard time getting her to try the place again. I on the other hand really like it, especially the fish with Cajun spices they offer blackened. I have dined on the vine covered patio and it is special ... what a feel ... and likewise what a view of the harbor area. Have also dined inside in the winter with the fireplace going. Really enjoyed both seasons there. I though the place was fairly reasonable and unlike my GF, I would suggest you try the place. In keeping with honesty, of all the times I have been there, this was the first I had a real sourpuss waitress that barked at me for asking a couple very simple menu questions. Thus the start was not good but the amazing patio atmosphere soon made me forget we had a puss face taking care of us. Again, split decision here, one thumbs up the other, thumbs down. It is worth your going to decide in my book.

We met up another couple recently for dinner and drinks to celebrate birthdays and I have to admit...we had a little trepidation due to many tepid reviews. However, we were all pleased with our meals, the server, Shirley, was first-rate, and to top it off, the food was 50% off because we were arrived between 4-6 pm during Winter hours! I started off with the She-Crab bisque, and it was amazing. I ordered the blackened Marlin (catch of the day) and it took me back to my days in N. Palm Beach living across the street from the Famous Atlantic Seafood Co. when outstanding, fresh seafood was a weekly occurrence. The rest of our group was very pleased with their selections of filet mignon, chicken and salad. You might want to give this hidden gem another play...like us, you may be pleasantly surprised. And you just can't beat the view

We almost didn't stop here for lunch because of the urbanspoon rating but I am so glad that we did. My husband and I were with 2 other couples and none of us could complain about the service or the food. Our waitress was great, she greeted us immediately, took our drink order (even explained that drinks had to be served in a plastic cup because we were outside) and shortly after returned for our food order. The menu had a lot of choices- italian to seafood to sandwiches. I can't find much to complain about- we would definitely go back!

Good food. I had she crab soup and lobster roll. Both were good. Right on the bay so the view is nice. Good food good service

Waterfront treat. Perhaps just a tad stale but certainly well-prepared food. Definitely a plus if you like seafood,otherwise the selection is limited. Wonderful place to eat and enjoy the bay.