Carsonie's - Westerville

The food was exceptional. I sat at the bar and enjoyed a fantastic Old Fashioned. I didn't have to wait long for my takeout order. My lasagna was delicious, and my wife's chicken parmesan was fantastic as well. We also tried the fried pickles and calamari, both of which were delicious.

The chicken stromboli was absolutely delicious. Our waitress was incredibly attentive and took care of all our requests. We'll definitely be returning to try the pizza next time!

For dessert, I indulged in the spumoni, which was absolutely delightful. I also appreciated the waitress’s thoughtful service—she didn’t rush me with the check and made sure to ask if I wanted dessert first. Her friendliness and attentiveness truly enhanced my dining experience. I can’t wait to return and try the stromboli next time, and I plan to bring my family along. Thank you for a lovely evening!

Even though we've lived in the area for quite some time, this was our first visit to Carsonie’s, and we've found our new favorite restaurant! My husband enjoyed a generous portion of spaghetti and meatballs, accompanied by a salad. The sauce was perfectly balanced, and the meatballs were tender and flavorful. The accompanying roll was a pleasant surprise—soft and fresh rather than the usual hard, crusty one. The salad was not only beautiful but also featured a delicious combination of fresh greens, tomatoes, and an amazing dressing. My flatbread pizza was unique and just right. Although there was a minor mix-up with our order, what stood out was how quickly and gracefully it was corrected. Our server, Jaimee S., was a delight—attentive and friendly, making her a real asset to the restaurant! We will definitely return for both takeout and dining in.

This lively and informal Italian restaurant offers a fantastic menu and a great selection of beers. While they are best known for their amazing calzones, I also enjoy their 8-inch pizzas, which are the perfect size and come with an extensive array of toppings. It's a wonderful spot for happy hour and a great place to catch up with friends over dinner.