Macarthur's At The Historic Thayer - Feedback

Spectacular view. Food was mediocre. Lunch sandwiches were just okay. Waitress seemed to have an attitude. Forgot soup and because of her attitude we didn’t bot...

It took over an hour to get our food and then most of our entrees were cool to cold. The server gave us 20% off (without us asking), but never came back to let...

The food was delicious. The staff was superb. We have nothing but great things to say about our experience. They were so accommodating to us all. I can’t say en...

A nice meal in a storied atmosphere. We walked in and were seated quickly. Service was very good. Meals were served hot and were delicious.

Not sure where all the negative reviews came from. Wait staff excellent and very accommodating towards my picky kids. Food was perfectly prepared and delivered...

Sadly, our server was not very attentive. Our drinks were not refilled, and my husband's steak was overcooked. They were kind enough to take it back, but by the...

We had the best table in the restaurant, on the porch with a view of the Hudson River. The service was excellent, and the food was delicious. It was a bit expen...

We have a tradition of celebrating our wedding anniversary at the MacArthur Restaurant, and this year was fantastic. The service was attentive and friendly, the...

The beet carpaccio was clever and delicious; the salmon was very good but the glaze was too thick and too sweet; the rice was clumpy and a little dry; the apple...

I want to like this restaurant but unfortunately there is no oversight, no good service and the food is sub par. They have a monopoly for West Point patrons and...