Randy's Neighbor's Inn - West Allis

Fish was okay, so were the French fries. It 's all you can eat. Service was a mix, waitress was nice but had no plates when the fish came and they forgot the bread and coleslaw.The place is a dump and not conducive to eating. Kind of like eating on card tables in my parents basement in the '60s and '70s.

Great fish fry...All you can eat for about $14. Really nice waitstaff!

They have all you can eat breaded cod on Friday for $14/person. They brought out a large hot plate of 8-9 large fillets. They were not greasy at all! Served with a bowl of creamy cole slaw, tarter sauce, half a lemon cut in half, and marble rye bread. Comes with fries and I cannot remember if they upcharge for substituting potato pancakes. I gave four stars because I prefer softer breading. Overall, the food was hot, good, and the staff is very friendly. I will be returning.

I enjoyed the fish fry. The Fish could of been fried a little longer for me

Not a bad stop for a fish fry, the cod is only okay but the value of all you can eat for a reasonable price and literally no wait time is hard to beat. The tap Blue Moon was flat, extremely flat. I would probably go back, so it’s worth a try if you’ve never had.