Good Fellas Pizza - Warrenton

The best pizza in the area! The crust is thin and the sauce is delicious. I work nearby Goodfellas and my coworkers and I usually order a pizza from there every week. I highly recommend it!

I conveniently timed my feedstore run with lunch. The crust and the marinara are the make or break for a pizza, calzone, Stromboli. Good Fellas Warrenton’s choice of ingredients and finesse— created a perfect combination of flavor and texture. Portions are enough to share, though I was grateful I didn’t have to share my dessert! Chocolate Mousse Cake— mmm made me chew slower out of pleasure! I am not a chef or a baker so I may get terms wrong (I’m just a foodie — it seemed to have like a thin layer of chocolate… like a ganache maybe, a dense cake that wasn’t heavy (how is that even possible?! with a very light and fluffy chocolate mousse between the layers. OMG. I will be back. The menu is extensive— I recommend checking it out before hand. I saw several other meals and desserts I look forward to trying, next visit.

I am still trying to understand why this restaurant has so many 5-star ratings. My expectations were very high, but I found the prices to be overly expensive. I could have bought 6-7 pizzas for the price of the 4 pies I purchased here. Unfortunately, I believe Domino's Pizza is better. They offer a variety of crusts and truly mean it when they say a 1-topping pizza can have any topping. I was disappointed to learn that this place advertised a 1-topping pizza special, but charged extra for any meat topping. Essentially, the special only included cheese and a vegetable topping, with sausage being an additional charge. This was my first and last visit to this restaurant. The cashier was very friendly, though - perhaps that is why they have so many 5-star ratings.

I will tell you this....class people, excellent food. Five stars isn't enough. Thank you!!!

I 'm always skeptical of Best of titles as Good Fellas was awarded this past year for the best pizza in Warrenton. Took me a bit to work up the courage to move away from Joe and Vinnies and Spitonys, but I 'm glad I tried them out. We had three large pizzas and a gluten-free pizza. All of them were solid, but my absolute favorite was the tandoori pizza. It was spectacular! It 's one of those pizzas that I 'll be craving again in a week.Update: We decided to try other dishes other than pizza and although the Philadelphia cheesesteak is okay, it 's by no means a Philadelphia cheesesteak. The meatball sub is about as good as Subway 's. In other words, not worth buying. Beyond pizza, I have to say that it 's a little bit disappointing.