Mama's Custom Cookies - Wantagh

Absolutely loved Mama's Custom Cookies! Ordered several nautical styles Sept. 2021 as treats for our wedding after party. They were so detailed, stunningly gorgeous AND they tasted amazing. They also merged our inspiration photos and requested color palette perfectly. Thanks so much!

We LOVED our custom cookies! They were very easy to work with. I would highly recommend!

I recently ordered cookies for my baby shower and they were perfect! They were made well, they were delicious and professionally packed (no broken or chipped cookies). Also, they were quick with responding to my questions….I wanted a different color so I reached out and I received a response within hours. Great cookies and customer service!! Highly recommend!

I ordered beauty and the beast cookies from her and I was not disappointed they were the most beautiful cookies I have ever seen and the cookies themselves were very tasty would definitely recommend this place to everybody and customer service was excellent love love this place

Our party planner had these cookies custom made for my sons mad science themed birthday party. Not only were they the most fantastic beaker, potion and scientific element shapes but they tasted fabulous. These folks are very talented!