New Bethel Ordinary - Feedback

Here's what you need to know: Local restaurant with out of this world pizza. Chunky veg with the cheese on top. Expanded outdoor seating for a good hang with fr...

I’m a fan of the deluxe pizza, but the restaurant is full of house flies. Bring your swatter.

Great beef brisket sandwich! The pork tenderloin strips are lovely as well.

I love this place. Kids and I have gone many times including my wife. The food is always good and the servers are great and the atmosphere is amazing.

Pizza was delicious and hot as always. Young lady who answered the phone was very pleasant.

A true hidden gem! I absolutely loved their daily drink specials. The fried dishes are simply *Koch's kiss*. The outdoor seating is beautiful!

Amazing pizza, Amazing people, at a great price. They have wings, bbq, sandwiches, salads and they serve it right! Large portions

Our family hadn't been here since the 1980s and decided to stop by for pizza and a beer. Let's just say, we were heavily disappointed. From what I've since lear...

I ordered a extra large supreme pizza. I receive my pizza under topped and undercut and not the cut that I specifically asked for. The price of the pizza went u...

This is Indiana Pizza. Holy cow, this is the heaviest pizza you can find without a top crust. It's impressive how much they fit on there. I saw a couple with a...

A literal hidden gem! Loved their daily drink specials. The fried food selection is *chef?s kiss* Lovely outdoor seating!

Great food and great friendly service. Has a separate bar area and many TVs in both areas. Lots of tasty items from pizza to wings sandwiches and even ham and b...

The food is excellent, and the service is very friendly. The restaurant features a separate bar area with plenty of TVs in both sections. There's a wide variety...

The staff here are very friendly and eager to help. The pizza is visually appealing and generously topped with cheese and other toppings, but unfortunately, it...

The staff is very friendly and accommodating. The pizza is visually appealing, loaded with cheese and toppings, but unfortunately, it was a bit bland. We had to...

It seems that I've always had an excellent experience each time I visit this restaurant, and tonight was no different. This is my first time writing a review on...

This is a wonderful pub for both a meal and a drink, complete with an upgraded patio area. I had a quesadilla with added pulled pork for lunch, and it was massi...

I have eaten at New Bethel Ordinary several times, and each experience has been wonderful. Most recently, I ordered a 16-inch pizza along with wings #9. The win...