Cattleman's Steakhouse And Lounge - Feedback

We arrived around 5pm there was 2 booths seated were asked if we had reservations? Every other table. Booth, was available. We were taken to the bar. That was a...

Oredered two ribeye steaks with side dishes!....And In conclusion Cattleman's Steakhouse in Sidney New York is the premier location for fine dinning! Shot out t...

First time visiting cattleman's. My wife and I ordered steak burgers. The server was friendly and attentive. The restaurant was empty on a Sunday afternoon (1:3...

I found this place on google while out in New York. It's rustic inside very western loved it! Our waitress was friendly, very bubbly and made sure we.had everyt...

There is an odd stench when you walk in. The food was decent and the wait staff was pleasant. However when the bill came we were told that they had just install...

Been trying to make a reservation for 3 days. If I am not kicked off the line. No one answers the phone. 3/10/23

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Dinner, Soup

Their wings were by far the best we've had in a long time would 100% go solely for the wings but if you do that you would miss out on the even better steak offe...

Service: Dine in Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Dinner Parking space Somewhat difficult to find parkin...

Very good food and service. It's worth the trip. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50

Nov 1, 2022: What's the deal with this place? Hard to find them open. Closed, again, today. From 3 Stars to 1. April 2021: The food itself was very good. We had...

Who puts 1000 Island dressing on Nachos? Even when I addressed the sauce our chicken BBQ bowl also had 1000 islands dressing on the rice. Paid $120 after tip fo...

There is an odd stench when you walk in. The food was decent and the wait staff was pleasant. However when the bill came we were told that they had just install...

July 27, 2022-Called the day prior and had to leave a message for a reservation-message was never returned. Called again the following day and made a reservatio...

Went here for Father's day today. My husband and I love getting the delmonico steak. We usually get it with the shrimp skewers added, but they ran out of them t...

Best steak hands down anywhere within 100 miles, the best waiter and good portions, which do not like this place not appreciate good food, but that is my opinio...

Meal took over an hour

The dinning service sucked! Ordered a prime rib and it was all fat! Not much meat! All fat and grizzle! Waited a long time for food and there were only a couple...

We are new to Sidney and curious about Cattlemen's Steakhouse which was closed for a few months. When it opened we had the holidays and several birthdays to cel...