Butler Inn Of Pewaukee

Rachel is beyond amazing!! We had drinks at the bar but then decided to also dine at the bar vs a table. Rachel was so accommodating and helpful and so kind. We will go back just for Rachel. Service like this almost doesn’t exist anymore. She’s that good. Thank you Rachel! You’re the best. The food and drinks were also outstanding.

Thank you for replying to every review except mine?$50 burger after delivery fees and tip. Seemingly Frozen patty ciabatta bun. $10 for cheese bacon and uncooked onion…….. this is not a gourmet burger. Should have got a fast food burger .

Treated our small group like royalty. The 5* tenderloin can’t be beat!WOW. Not 1 bad thing to mention.

My Wife and I will travel a bit to eat here with friends two or three times a year. Never a bad experience...until last night. The perch was pedestrian, salad somewhat lifeless and the atmosphere was dull. The wait staff was kinda salty. The bartender didn't engage with us when we asked about a drink she was making, one of their specialties.....almost annoyed that we asked. Our Waitress was solid, but she too made us feel like we were a chore. Probably not going back, not with that weak a value propostion.

I took friends to Butler Inn for a fish fry. We were absolutely happy with the entire evening! Friendly people, beautiful place, wonderful food!