Garden City Pub

Don't really see what the hype was all about. Service was good and the drinks were on point. We order three different flavors of wings on top of our regular orders and it was pretty disappointing. Size and texture was fine but all three lacked taste. We might give it another shot in a few weeks.

Love this place fun and lots of food choices. Of course the wings are the best. Friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere.

Stopped for late dinner. Good to see they still have an overwhelming and impressive beer list. Hubby had turkey burger with cheddar/bacon but thought it was a little dry. I had a burger made of short ribs with a layer of Mac Cheese in place of a slice of cheese. And it was a substantial burger! Just awesome: moist, cheesy, and great comfort food. Sorry, forgot to take photos. (Hey, we were hungry) Typical boisterous crowd that can get loud when busy. Very attentive server.

I visited on a Saturday with two friends and was seated immediately. Our server was friendly, attentive, and efficient. The food arrived promptly, and the sweet potato fries were, as always, delicious. It had been a long time since my last visit, but returning brought back fond memories of hanging out with friends here. The Moscow Mule Blueberry drink was tasty, and while my chicken sandwich was a bit dry, I made the most of it. Overall, the experience was enjoyable, and the service was great. The ambiance remained unchanged, maintaining its cozy pub like atmosphere so dark that it took a moment for my eyes to adjust to the sunlight when I stepped outside! Minor quibbles aside, it was a pleasant visit.

Been to Croxleys a bunch of times over the years. The food is consistent but the service is not. On 4/2/24, we had Allison and she was great. She was honest, friendly and attentive. We shared medium wings (well done with a puddle), nachos with chili and a blackened chicken quesadilla. All items were served hot and staggered as requested. The wings were meaty and the quesadilla was well stuffed. For some reason the soda is always flat tasting, fyi. Food 4 stars Service 5 stars Ambience 4 stars (bar atmosphere)