Gaetano Pizza Cafe

The best pizza hands down.... If you are driving anywhere near Brewster you need to stop by and get a slice..... Any style any toppings... They are all great! A must have!

Stopped in after a 14 hour drive. Picked up a meatball Parm and a chicken Parm plus 2 Cokes. Total was $27, which to me seems a little high, but it was pretty good. I would probably do it again...

The Pizza is good, thin crispy crust. Strombolis and Jamaican Patties pretty good too. Always a good variety and the service is polite.

Great place for a quick bite to eat after a home depot run.

I would definitely come back here again. Have a wide variety of pizza, soups pastas, calzones, etc. It’s very popular with the locals. They also offer various desserts. I knocked down a star because the bathroom can use increased cleaning. I feel like those pizzas be a little less crunchy.