Nicholas Creamery - Tinton Falls

Middletown location 12-14 people in line, 2 girls working one is serving customers the other is Stacking cups on full stacks already on counter, terrible customer service, great ice

Friendly and helpful staff.Delicous ice cream.Great flavors (standard and special).

Went here for the first time this weekend and it was well worth the trip ! I got the nachos ice cream box with Whoopie pie strawberries and cream and cookies n cream all flavors were amazing the hot fudge was so good ! Definitely will be coming back

We visited this Nicholas Creamery location specifically to try the Italian rainbow flavor and it did not disappoint! The whoopie pie flavor we also got was delicious as well. Prices were high but not ridiculous, and service was fast. Great ice cream.

Get the Tahitian Vanilla... Some of the finest ice cream on the Jersey ShoreKid-friendliness: I brought my 3 daughters. They loved the bench shaped like a cow