Nancy's Pizza Express - Tinley Park

I actually don't really like deep dish pizza because of the dough to topping ratio (I'm a thin crust and brick oven pizza kind of girl) but my boyfriend loves it so of course we had to get some while in Tinley Park. I give Nancy's 2 thumbs up! We got the 1.5' cheese pizza and I think they bake the cheese into the dough... I don't know how they do what they do but it was so good!!! The dough tasted really good (reminded me of a little of the crust on Pizza Hut's personal pan pizza) and it wasn't too much for the amount of cheese. I also love cheese so the ooey gooey cheesy goodness of this pizza was perfection.

We absolutely love this restaurant! We frequently order the godmother sandwiches, and they are simply the best. If you're a fan of chicken parmigiana sandwiches, you'll adore these. We don't even bother trying other places anymore because they just can't compare. The garlic bread is wonderfully buttery and crispy, perfectly complementing the chicken. The service here is fantastic as well; it's great to feel that our patronage is valued.

I absolutely love their pizza, whether it's thick or thin! The service is fantastic as well—always quick and friendly. They addressed an issue I had with a previous order without any hassle. If you're looking for something else, definitely try the Italian beef sandwich; it's amazing! Although I'm not in their delivery area, when I crave pizza, I always make the trip to Nancy's in Tinley. They deserve 11 stars!

The pizza was fantastic! However, it was only available for takeout. The online listing mentioned that dining in was an option, but they didn’t allow it. We drove from Indiana expecting to eat inside, only to find out that wasn't possible. So, we ended up enjoying our pizza in the car, which was quite messy but absolutely delicious!

This is the best Nancy's I've ever experienced. The food is excellent, and the service is top-notch—fast delivery, accurate orders, and friendly drivers.