Enrico’s Pizza - Tavernier

Enrico's Pizza in Islamorada, FL is an absolute gem! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted with warm hospitality and a cozy ambiance. The menu offers a delightful array of artisanal pizzas, and each bite was bursting with authentic flavors. The ingredients tasted fresh, and the crust was perfectly crispy yet tender.The service was impeccable, with attentive staff who catered to our every need. The attention to detail in presentation made the dining experience even more enjoyable.We had the eggplant pizza and it has to be the best pizza I’ve ever tasted! The chef was very welcoming in coming outside to greet us and ask us about our dining experience.Enrico's dedication to quality shines through every aspect of the restaurant, creating an unforgettable culinary journey. I highly recommend this 5-star restaurant to anyone visiting Islamorada. You won't be disappointed!

Fantastic pizza and pizza accessories! The wait staff are a bit inexperienced and disorganized, but it is definitely worth going. Call for take out vs ordering online.

Our server who I think his name was Corey was very helpful and explained the menu to us. The pizza was delicious and the atmosphere outside is inviting. Would definitely come again!

We specifically went there for the cheesecake. We actually purched a whole one. The reason was last year we visited and had the best key lime pie with a pecan and carmel) crust vs. traditional graham cracker. Needless to say, tlwe were disappointed it was NOT what we had last year. : ?

Great food, AMAZING service, my family had Sophie as our server, she was great. We had a pepperoni and a cheese pizza, it was very good. The garlic rolls are a MUST!! And for desert we had the most amazing chocolate cake. There was nice Italian music in the background and the cooks were very friendly. I will be going back!!