New York New York Pizza - Tampa

From New Jersey in the 90s it came a few years to find a decent pizzeria until NY Pizza came. have been customer for years and must say that while inflation is crawling and understanding that a business must remain profitable, selling pizza was and is still a very profitable business. Unfortunately, NY Pizza has reduced its portions and always very stingy. I usually order a big cake and what a regular cheese, must now be double cheese to make it decent. Sauce is almost not existent now. Oh, my, what can I say to pay his sad, now $22 for a big cake that is no longer halfway decent. Management, please note that it is not too late to come back to what NY Pizza was earlier.

Taste this pizza for the first time tonight and it was delicious. After my first bite I yelled?best pizza ever?. I never had New York Pizza in NY, but I was told about my husband from NY, it's the closet I had. I loved it. Staff super beautiful (whatever is a plus). Recommend without reservations. Tania Roman

Order white pizza for my birthday after reading wonderful reviews. Terrible! Burnt, slightly black crust, asparagus mozzarella cheese all dried, not plump, or gooey, saw and tasted like days old cheese. No! Garlic and the Ricotta cheese make a white pizza! Ricotta cheese was okay. Again, the whole ricotta cheese was hard and dried. ..supposed to be wet, with buttery garlic taste. It was Friday night at 8:00. Nobody sat and you burned the pizza? Ate a piece and bring it back tomorrow to get my $20 back.

Order on UberEats came here to check because the pizza was so delicious! Best pizza I had in Tampa, and I eat too much pizza. Where was this pizza my whole life?! Will definitely order again. Pizza has a large NY thin crust and a crispy, light and airy crust edge. The pizza sauce must be made house, it is made clear with fresh tomatoes and garlic. Absolutely amazing. Great stuff. I'm crazy, I ate everything I want more.

SO GOOD! Love the thin, crispy (almost lightly charred) crust. Definitely reminds me of NJ/NY style. They've got a friendly staff, quick kitchen, and actually pay attention to Toast orders!! I've had many forgotten dressings or sides elsewhere but NYNY Pizza got everything right ? Also- try the garlic knots. Phenomenal