Sutter's Mill - Suffern

Haven't been here in some time, so thought we'd stop in. It was 75 cent wing night, so my husband and I ordered 10 Buffalo wings each. We were offered Bleu cheese, and said yes, without being told there was an upcharge. Our daughter ordered fried pickles and the Italian combo, which she declared delicious. The wings were so overcooked, they were more like chicken jerky. The waffle fries were very good, and it was a large portion. Considering they do wing night every Tuesday, to serve wings like that at a place like this, is nothing short of disgraceful. Also, it was in the midst of a heatwave, and the a/c was barely working. Overall, very disappointing.

Exceptional on Hospitality flavor?. Get a little to eat or a bite to eat.

Went there after playing round of golf at spook rock. One of the best smash burgers that I've ever had.

Came to the restaurant at 2:20 pm in the afternoon and it was closed. No sign on the door, just locked up. Looked at the hours prior to coming here and it stated it was open on Mondays. Is that not the case? If so, you should update the hours on Google so people don’t show up and wind up leaving dissatisfied.

We live in Tennessee were here visiting friends. We opted to eat here and although the food was 3 star there were other issues. 1) The restaurant has a cold entry, a door, dead zone, door. The dead zone smelled like excrement. There was a man in the area on his phone so maybe....they opened the outer door to air it out 2) We seated ourselves, but when the waitress brought the menus she did not take our drink order. We did tell her we were waiting an another, but she still should have taken our drink order. 3) When we placed our drink order I ordered sweet tea then was reminded we are in the north, so I ordered a Dr. Pepper, she brought me a Mr. Pibb. I thought about saying something because had she told me they did not have Dr. Pepper I would have went with Coke. She did not tell me, she subsisted my order without giving me any options. 4) My wife ordered a veggie burger wrapped in lettuce, the waitress brought back a regular hamburger with bacon. 5) The restaurant had no regular mustard ANYWHERE in their entire place. 6) She seldom checked on us and I ran out of drink 2xs. My bill was over $100 but because we are in America where tip shaming is common I still left an 19% tip. Since we live 845 miles away I doubt anything would ever be done to make any of this right. But I was very disappointed with the service, more so since I was seeing a good friend, and paying the bill.