Stonington Ice Cream Company

Delicious lobster rolls and fresh baguette, but the kitchen was a bit dirty for comfort.

Love it here!! The owner is so awesome and has a fantastic gallery next door! The sandwiches are delicious and the menu includes staples such as lobster rolls but also features rotating sandwiches with delicious creative and inspired recipes. The ice cream is fantastic as well!

A friend raved about this sandwich and told us it was a must try next time we were in the area. Well it definitely wasn't an $18 sandwich. You are given some wonderfully smoked and delicious haddock that unfortunately was placed between a regular, dry hamburger bun; then this gets iceberg lettuce and a slice of tomato with mayonnaise that may have dried basil in it. Besides the haddock everything just took away from the fish and didn't add anything too it. Honestly a real aioli wouldn't even be needed since the fish was so flavorful, but maybe a light lemon vinaigrette with sliced onions and romaine hearts on a toasted brioche bun. Or just serve the fish on its own as it was the star. Oh...it does come with a bag of cape cod chips if that does it for you.

Wonderful staff, ice cream and a lovely lobster roll with green onions and chips. Will be back next time we are in town!

Smoked salmon sandwich and Lobster roll were both incredible!