Tony's Original's Pizzeria

The last two years or so I have tried different pizza places on staten island, I must have tried at least two dozen since the finish. tony’s original pizza, a small business in tompkinsville, was a place I found when I drove from work to home. I didn't expect much of it because it was hidden behind the victorious boulevard. I was incredibly wrong. the pizza is incredible. I have half a mushroom cheesecake. after a 30-minute drive the pizza was still moist and the crust is incredible. even after micro-weaving, the crust still keeps its moistness and is perfectly crisp. the sauce, the cheese and the toppings are really fresh and are not stale at all. this place is incredible and I highly recommend it.

Over the past couple of years, I've been exploring various pizza spots on Staten Island and have sampled at least two dozen since the lockdown. One hidden gem I discovered is Tony's Original Pizza, a charming little shop in Tompkinsville that I stumbled upon while driving home from work. I didn't have high expectations since it’s tucked away behind Victory Boulevard, but I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza is outstanding. I ordered a half mushroom, half cheese pie, and even after a 30-minute drive, it arrived still moist with an amazing crust. Remarkably, the crust retained its moisture and crispness even after reheating in the microwave. The sauce, cheese, and toppings are all incredibly fresh and far from stale. This place is truly exceptional, and I highly recommend it!

This is hands down the best pizzeria on Staten Island; it's the only place I would ever consider ordering from!

This is hands down the best pizzeria on Staten Island; it's the only place I would ever consider ordering from.

The pizza here is fantastic, and the couple at the front is incredibly kind. They always express their gratitude and greet you with a smile. If I lived closer, this would definitely be my go-to pizzeria!