Tony's Pizza New York Style

My family and I had spent an entire day traveling to reach our vacation destination and wanted a quick dinner. We tried this establishment and couldn't have been happier. We called in our pizza, the person on the phone was extremely nice and personable. My husband and father went to pick up the pizza were they were met with quick and pleasant service. The white pizza with chicken and onions added and the supreme pizza were both fantastic. We would definitely recommend this family oriented restaurant to anyone looking for an amazing pizza! ???

We enjoyed some traditional NY pizza at Tony’s. Super busy place, so have your order on your mind before you jump in line. Despite them being busy, we were able to get in and out within 15 minutes or so but…we were there during the “off season” for tourists. I’ve heard the line can wrap around the corner on most days. It’s a cash only establishment but there is an ATM outside if you need it. They have a few places to sit down inside but they’ll most likely be filled with other people. There’s a nice little park across the street where you can grab a park bench and chow down. There’s also a store next door where you can grab a soda.

It is obvious they do not want people to dine in. They only had a booth or 2 that could even be sat in (and they were dirty). All the other booths were covered in pizza boxes. Wasn't a very welcoming environment.

Our pizza was great! We loved it and our service was fantastic! We ate curbside after spending some time across the street at Crescent Beach. I would recommend both the pizza and the beach!

Mediocre pizza at best. They said it would take 35 minutes, it took almost an hour. Probably won't return.