Cold Stone Creamery - South Orange

The cookie mintster is usually great, but this time there was very little fudge and cookies. Still awesome though!

I was very disappointed with my experience at this restaurant. The ice cream was blended like a shake instead of having toppings, and I paid extra for hot fudge and a sugar cone but did not receive either. Additionally, the so-called peanut butter cookie dough ice cream did not even taste like peanut butter.

One of the items was not what we ordered and the one that was correct was poorly made and had traces of peanut butter. They would never get away with such haphazard preparation if I were ordering in person. They take advantage of the fact that you have little recourse once you receive the order. Fortunately, DD refunded the incorrect item.

I received the smallest amount of ice cream I've ever gotten in a cup at Coldstone, but my order was correct.

Asked for extra extra sprinkles and reciev barely any