Buttercooky Bakery - Smithtown

Always loved the butter cook in the flower park, now they have opened an in hunting tone. the desserts are fabulous. especially they love the miniature cakes that they rehearse they have to order size. but I don't think you can go wrong with one of them. my personal favorite is the fruity cake. wet white cake with layers of custard and filled with fresh fruits with fresh whipped cream icing. now the bakery opened the caffe, where they can order breakfast or lunch. I had both. the paninis are fantastic as well as the breakfast sandwiches. I was pleasantly surprised with freshly made ingredients. nothing frozen or microshafted. Maybe I was the freshest ommelette I've ever had. hesitated to write a review bc I don't want to wait to come when the word comes out. came back several times and everything is fabulous. can be the best breakfast / noon option in huntington.

Our venue has not delivered a cake so we were on our own search for a bakery. we heard so many great reviews about buttercooky and thought we would give them a try. we had a great experience with the cake tasting and booked them in advance. our cake came out exactly as we had hoped!

This use to be the bakery of choice I have tried them again only to be disappointed for the second time in 4 months. I have ordered cakes on both occasions only to get cake with so much Icing and very little Cake I should have just ordered a icing cake. I will not be returning these cakes are not cheap and the quality has really fallen off tremendously They are taking one small cake and cutting it so thin and making the height up with tons is icing

Delicious! nice personal. clean. beautiful displays. great renovations to this fantastic and wonderful bakery. I host an annual oktoberfest and make sure I stop here for the fantastic desserts. their apple strudel, apple turnover, boston cream doughnuts and jelly doughnuts are the best. love this place!

Everything is absolutely delicious here! there is so much to choose, but not enough time to eat everything! the cannoli’s are fresh at the place, the cakes are extremely fresh and moist. if they are looking for a dessert to take a family or friends home, they will not be disappointed!