Pinecaft Ice Cream - Siesta Key

Excellent location on main street of Siesta Key Village with easy access via the Free Trolley. Indoor and outdoor seating options available. So many flavors to choose from. My favorite is one scoop of Toasted Coconut and one scoop of Rum Raisin...tastes like vacation!! Don't be detered by a long line, it moves quick and their ice cream is well worth the short wait! Enjoy!!

It was okay. I've had much better. We enjoyed sitt outside on one of their benches people watching while are our ice cream.

The ice cream here was fantastic! It's definitely a unique spot to visit, especially when paired with Riptide Pizza down the street. The price for the big Olaf cone with two scoops was excellent. I also enjoyed the outdoor seating area. Overall, I would rate it a 10 out of 10!

We visited the ice cream shop with the family today, and based on the reviews, we were expecting a better flavor experience. Unfortunately, the ice cream fell short. The birthday cake flavor lacked actual birthday cake and only offered a sprinkle taste. The base of the ice cream seemed bland, with the flavors mainly coming from the mix-ins. I found it overly sweet and fatty. The gelato places next door and the Sub Zero around the corner are far superior for my taste. Although this place is pricey, the scoops are gigantic—each of us ordered two scoops, and no one was able to finish their ice cream.

This homemade ice cream and fudge shop has been around for ages, which says a lot about its quality. They offer a wide variety of flavors, making it a bit challenging to pick just one. My personal favorite is the Snickers flavor, and it's absolutely delicious!