The Islander - SHELTER ISLAND

Great selection of options and efficient service. Please note that it's cash only. Regular customers have their mugs displayed beneath the specials board. They offer a wide range of local beers. I particularly enjoyed the pancakes and sausage.

This restaurant is a true gem. The decor is lovely and vibrant, and the menu offers a fantastic selection. We enjoyed omelettes and pancakes, while our child had chicken nuggets and fries. The salads appeared very fresh and generous, and the burgers looked equally enticing. The service was friendly, and the location is conveniently situated in the center of the island. We will definitely return. It’s a great spot for families, friends, or even solo diners. We noticed many people opting for takeout during our visit as well.

The food was good, but the service was very slow. I wasn't kept informed about any issues.

Great place to bring a family, very cozy. Service has always been great never an issue.

The food here is made to order, fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious! The counter waitress had an incredible rapport with all the regulars, exuding vibrant positivity and friendliness even towards newcomers. While we waited for our tasty lunch to be prepared, we learned a lot about the history of Shelter Island, particularly how the summer population swells from 2,500 to 25,000. We talked about apartment prices, taxes, schools, and shopping spots. All I can say is, keep the love and food coming... I can't wait to return for one of those enormous burger plates!