Rita's Italian Ice In Seaford

This Rita's is hands down the best I've ever visited. They consistently get my orders right and make an effort to accommodate some unusual requests. My daughter enjoys her vanilla custard served in a cup with chocolate sprinkles at the bottom, followed by the custard, more sprinkles on top, and then a cone. It's a quirky combination! Although the way items are packaged for delivery makes it challenging to follow instructions perfectly, today they included the cone separately, demonstrating their commitment to doing their best. This Rita's never lets me down!

The eyo peanut butter jelly flavor ice was truly the best flavor I’ve ever tasted—an absolute delight! It’s exactly what you’d expect, but even better. It pairs perfectly with vanilla or strawberry custard. Please don't ever get rid of this flavor!

The ice cream had a smell similar to spoiled milk, and to make matters worse, I found bugs in my cup.

Their Italian ices are the best! Reminds me of my childhood.

Ordered multiple times and its always delicious. Was sent a plain Italian ice and not a gelati this time on accident. App was easy to use to refund the extra I paid. I will order again.