Mr. Trustee Creamery - S San Diego

A perfect addition to the Mission Hills neighborhood for a sweet treat. They rotate flavors regularly and also have their usual soft serve options, too. The Robin’s Egg flavor for Spring is absolutely delicious.A bit bummed that they no longer offer their “pup cup” for dogs, but not a deal breaker.

Andes Avalanche is incredible for mint chocolate lovers.

I waited 1.5 years until they offered a coconut option and I finally got one: coconut cream pie. I paid ten dollars (w/tip) for this medium size scoop in a waffle cone. Sigh. The Crunchies in the ice cream were good, but where was the butterfat? And where was the coconut shreds or flavor of any kind? If a coconut ice cream is not creamy smooth wonderful than what will other flavors be like??? I guess that Hammonds Gourmet ice cream in North Park or Point Loma remains King of the Butterfat Hill!

Great flavors here! Rich and flavorful but it won't be my favorite spot for icecream. While the portions are generous and the flavors are pretty good, the cookies and cream left a weird coating on my mouth. Typically I see just the cookie component mixed into icecream, but it tasted like they threw the whole Oreo in there and the cream part wasn't mixing in very well. Overall, pretty good and if I was in the mood for icecream and lived nearby, I would stop in. Otherwise I'd probably stick to my other go to spot.

I am usually a salt and straw or handels girl but was pleasantly surprised with the amazing flavors and perfect balance of creaminess and sweetness with this ice cream. I got the little Debbie and lemon meringue flavors and they both knocked it out of the park! Will definitely be back!!