New York Pizza Co - Riverside

I was looking for something to eat and drove by the restaurant. I passed it up on my way to in-N-out but I soon realized that pizza sounded so much better than a burger and fries. It was one of the best decisions I could have ever made. I wasn't sure what to expect from a box on the corner but soon reminded that you don't judge a book by its cover. I must say that this was by far the best pizza I've had in so many years. I ended up giving a $10 dollar tip. The service was an easy five star. The food was an outstanding five star. This is my new go to place for Italian food. Thank you for your service.

I thought there was a little bit too much sauce. I got a pan pizza and it was cold. The crust of the pizza was really good and crunchy, but I think they pre-cook it and that is why it was cold. They put a lot of cheese, they are not skimpy on toppings. So I guess it is up to someone taste buds as to how good it was, this is just my opinion.

Awesome New York style pizza! Their prices are reasonable as well

I had high expectations from this place since I love pizza, I was expecting exceptional pizza since it 's one of the few spots offering world famous New York pizza ..... Not impressed and I 'm sorry but the sauce was missing something, flavor wasn 't there for me. Maybe new york style pizza ain 't for me ?

This was one of the WORST,WORST,WORST dining experiences we've ever had! My wife ordered a 10 with onion, green peppers and basil. I ordered a 10 with pineapple and black olives, an order of cheesy bread and a couple of drinks... 50 bucks. Which I could have stomached if the food was good... we ordered it to eat there, after sitting there for 5 minutes, first, looking for a clean chair... which there were none, the outside(only) eating area was disgustingly, deplorably... filthy, the chairs seats were dirty... looked like they'd never been cleaned, the arm trails on the chairs were so dirty I was afraid to move them... the floor also looked like it had never been cleaned and the smell of the dirty trash cans made me feel like I was sitting next to a dirty dumpster, not to mention the traffic noise... so we decided to get our food to go... Then the pizzas... it looked like they pre-make cheese pizzas and when you order, they throw the toppings on and maybe put it in the oven for a minute... pizza was hot, but my pineapple and olive were cold, like they'd just come out of the can... my wife's onions were raw... no browning whatsoever and the basil leaves were still whole and not even wilted. Then the taste, bland and no flavor... to top it off, the l guys working there didn't wear gloves and had their noses out of their mask... given the complete lack of cleanliness of the place, absolutely disgusted my wife, when we got home, she tried one slice... bite off her pizza and decided to make a sandwich. The cheesy bread was also raw. What would it take to get a pressure washer and wash down the eating areas and furniture and trash cans... this is a place completely mismanaged and where the owners and employees don't care. I've been to New York many times and this is an embarrassment to call this New York style pizza... Will NEVER return or order from this place again.