Pleasantville Pizzeria

This could very well be the best pizzeria in Mt. Pleasant. The Sicilian pizza is exceptional, but it can be challenging to place an order after 7:30 or 8:00 as they tend to close early. It's definitely worth making the effort to try again.

Very good Pizza made with attention to detail. Eat in or take out.

I am a long time pizza aficionado born and bred in Brooklyn, and I love the pizza here. Whenever I am nearby I make sure to stop in for a slice. I'm not sure what makes the pizza here great, but I am guessing it is a combination of the wheat flour, kneading and leavening, the cheese, and lots of love. Definitely what I remember from my childhood days in Brooklyn. It's a small takeout with limited seating inside and some additional seating outside, right next to the train station. Plenty of parking. Enjoy!

The pizza here is a delightful example of classic New York-style thin crust, and their calzones are quite good as well. They primarily offer whole pies, priced around $20, with about 25 different options available, though they do have 3-4 individual slices on hand. The staff is friendly, and there’s a good amount of seating both indoors and outdoors. They also cater to gluten-free diets with options like cauliflower crusts. In addition to pizza, they serve Italian ice, calzones, heroes, wedges, salads, and more. Be aware that there’s a $15 minimum order for free delivery in Pleasantville. The pizza was enjoyable, featuring a nice crispness, though the sauce could use a bit more seasoning for added flavor. The calzone, packed with cheese, was definitely a great deal at $6.

The man at the counter is really friendly! Pizza is very good, and food is ready quickly.