Pizzeria New York - Pickerington

This is the best pizza in Pickerington! While it may not be exactly like what you’d find in NYC or NJ, it’s fantastic for the east side of Columbus!

I ordered online and my pizza came out of the oven right on time—absolutely delicious! I will definitely be coming back in the future. The pizza was fantastic, and the timing was expertly managed to ensure it was as fresh as possible.

Do not sleep on this place! My family and I visited on a weeknight, and the place was completely empty. Considering how good the pizza is, we were shocked. Although, I imagine the vast majority of their business is pickup orders. The cheese and crust wereabsolutely perfect, and I believe they could hold their heads high anywhere in New York. The only drawback in my mind is thatthe didn?t have a waitstaff (considering how large and open a space it is! . You have to do all your ordering at the counter,and you get paper plates, plastic cups, and no ice. That all could be a lot better, but it?s still amazing pizza.

This restaurant was recommended to me by a friend, but I found it to be quite disappointing. Having grown up in New York, I know what authentic New York-style food should taste like, and this wasn't it. The pizza was mediocre, and the bread knots were lacking flavor. The only standout item was the onion rings, which were decent. However, the overall cleanliness of the place was concerning—it appeared dirty and dusty, and it seemed as though they were in the process of moving rather than fully open for business. While the staff was polite, they definitely seemed overworked and less attentive than they should have been. Unfortunately, I can't recommend this place, and I won't be coming back.

Had an excellent NY style pizza as you would expect! Delicious! Great salad as well!