Petaluma Pie Company

I have never tasted a better pie before! The best American pie in Petaluma!

Oh my goodness! I ordered a small Lemon Meringue pie and it was the best I have ever tasted! I intended to only eat half of it, but I couldn't resist and ended up finishing the whole pie. I highly recommend this restaurant! The dessert was absolutely delicious! Go try it!

My girlfriend and I visited this restaurant in Petaluma during our trip and we were very disappointed. Despite pies being their main specialty, they failed to impress us. When we asked if they could warm up the fruit pie, we were told no. We ended up ordering the coconut cream pie, but it was absolutely terrible. It had a bad texture and lacked any flavor. We couldn't even finish it. Save your money and skip this place.

Who celebrated Pi Day on March 14th?3.1415926535...It was quick to order the day before and fortunately there was a break in weather so there wasn't a downpour when it was time to pickup those delicious small pies! The staff were friendly and their display cases were stocked with lots of other pie flavors too like The Elvis, Banana Cream, more Lemon and more pumpkin. So glad I pre-ordered!Thank you Petaluma Pie Company for the yummy treats to help us celebrate Pi Day (and Einstein's bday too)!

Amazing spot to pick up some sweet and savory pies. They even offer local delivery! The chocolate cream is my favorite. Service if always fast and friendly.