Tiffany's Cafe - Peekskill

I basically went there for their hot Cheetos elote after I saw pictures online. Apparently, they had that for a limited time. The host personally came up, spoke to us and said they don't have it as a standard item on the menu. But would like to make it for us. They came out looking and tasted delicious!!!! Everything was great; food, service, quality. They even served complementary dessert.

Had the most delicious dinner at Tiffany’s in Peekskill. All the food was super fresh tasty. We ordered a few different things because we wanted to really give it a good try. Support this local spot. We found parking right outside which was very convenient. Let’s talk about the ceviche. It’s made to order and takes about 15 minutes and is worth the wait. I’d wait an hour for it. It’s literally that good. The ceviche had a bursting flavor of citrus but not too powerful, just the right amount of spice and seasoning. All the ingredients were perfectly and freshly chopped. The presentation was also lovely, served up in an ornate cocktail glass. I’m very picky about guacamole and find that eating it out isn’t always the best choice but Tiffany’s makes the BEST GUAC! It’s fresh, not too chunky and not too smooth. Every bite is better than the next. The chips are dusted with chili lime salt and it’s just a party in your mouth. The milkshakes were delicious and not too thick. They were just the right consistency and sweetness. We ordered the strawberry milkshake that was served with strawberry churros which were the best churros I’ve ever had (they were warm, rolled in cinnamon sugar and filled with a strawberry compote). The Oreo milkshake was just as delicious. I can go on about how good this place is. It’s really really really good I highly recommend it for a nice low key casual dinner that’s fun, nutritious tasty.

I thought the food was good here overall. I have the tacos and my wife had a shrimp dish. The shrimp dish was the better of the two. I would definitely come back again for a quick bite to eat. The service was very good.

If you come across this little restaurant in your search for a place to eat, I say do it! You will not be disappointed. It’s a small place but very clean and cute. Our server was so genuine and attentive our entire time there, and the food was amazing. We had brunch, but we went through the menu and can say they have an extremely wide variety of foods from American, Italian, to various Hispanic country foods. They served us homemade chips with this delicious home made sauce while we waited for our meals. We highly recommend you try this place out. We will definitely be going back.

First time here, it was too yummy. The guy upfront was nice and the shrimp Alfredo, baked fish dish was flavorful.