Paia Gelato Best Gelato In Maui

The staff are incredibly friendly and eager to offer samples and explain the different flavors. The gelato was absolutely delicious too!

I had a fantastic experience after dinner! The gelato was absolutely delicious, and the sorbet was a must-try. The staff was friendly, humorous, and courteous. Based on their recommendation, I decided to mix lilikoi and raspberry in my cup, and it was excellent!

Best Gelato in Maui! Super friendly service. Sean is the best! And the rest of the team, too. You get generous samples before you decide, but for us all flavors were fantastic.

I had a disappointing experience at this restaurant due to poor service. Their hours indicate they are open until 10:00 PM, so we only double-checked because many places in Maui have misleading hours. A young staff member informed us they were closing at 8:00 PM that day. Luckily, we called ahead. We drove all the way there and arrived at 7:30 PM, only to find the doors locked. It's frustrating when a business doesn’t uphold its advertised hours. I called around 6:50 PM on Monday, September 19, 2022.

Extremely delicious! I got the dark chocolate and haupia. Flavors were rich with balanced sweetness.