It's Toney's Coney's Time's - Newalla

Always wondered about this place so I decided to go out on limb and give them a try because there's always a line of cars wrapped around the building. When I pull up I discover that the line of cars is not because their food is mind blowing or word of mouth but because they don't have a modern drive thru system. They have a all seasons menu board or sign and then you order from your car to a person who takes your order, you pay, then you drive to the next window and pick up your food. You might as well walk in and order yourself because it's the same difference. Not too much digital, kiosk, or speaker systems going on here as the place screams serious MAGA vibes. Nevertheless the guy taking my order was extremely friendly, courteous, and professional. Now to the food. These chili dogs could be made at home with items picked up from ALDIs or Krogers which is not a bad thing but it's like for me if I'm eating out I'd like to taste something unique and not run of the mill. For example, yes you can get Skyline Chili Dog sauce from Krogers but if you order chili dogs from one of their restaurants it's something unique in how it's prepared and executed that just can't quite emulate at home. This point brings me back to this place where you can clearly pull of their dogs, and probably make them better and cheaper if you put in the effort by going to the grocery store and doing them yourself. I prefer an all beef hotdog like a Hebrew National and the hot dogs were definitely your standard fare with the filler/pork/chicken mix etc I guess to keep the cost down. The bun on the one with the works with the Krogers tasting coleslaw on top was extremely soggy. They've got other stuff like malts, fries, onion rings etc but I assumed they'd taste like Krogers or Gordon Food Services items and didn't feel like trying because my expectations were not high. I could be wrong. 4 Stars because even from outwardly appearance of the place it evokes a sense of nostalgia for the surrounding community and looks to have been a staple here for generations which is why I guess people from the surrounding community regularly patronize this place. A few years back they opened up a Franks a little further down on West Broad and nobody gave a damn and it closed down pretty quick. Although Franks is a FAR SUPERIOR and way better tasting hot dog joint, unfortunately it didn't register with the west side of Columbus area community. Moreover although brief, I got excellent customer service and that goes a long way with me. Also 4 stars for the soggy buns and overall taste. Again it's not bad, Just not unique and easily duplicated.

Love this place. It's small. Local. Great food. Great prices. Great service. Has a little outside patio and a drive thru. Sometimes we just crave coneys and this is where we want them from. Great shakes and fries too. Always on our list. If you haven't tried it out, you should!

If you're looking for good food at affordable prices with straightforward working class service, this is your place. I loved it. Cheeseburgers and onion rings, Italian Sun with fries solid simple and tasty. Service is quick. Place is comfortable.

So good! A hidden gem on the west side. Coneys are amazing. Ice cream is delicious. Great prices too!

I love Toney's Coneys. I've been going here with my family all my life even took my children as they grew up. Now they are taking my grandbabies!. If you like/love coneys a great dessert of many kind in the ice cream, slurping way love to make friends reminiss about the old days over a cup of coffee then this is YOUR PLACE to go enjoy! Open year round in hear of New Rome at 5266 W Broad St, Columbus, OH, United States, Ohio.