Gino's Trattoria Pizzeria Of New Hyde Park

I was feeling a bit unwell after Thanksgiving, so I decided to have some soup. You absolutely have to try the fish soup! It was delicious and fulfilling. The combination of calamari and shrimp in a flavorful broth with a hint of spice was fantastic. Every spoonful was packed with flavor. Give it a shot!

My wife ordered the Chicken Marsala, but the sauce was quite different from what we expected. It was a reddish-brown color, rather than the usual deep brown, and it was also thin and lacking in flavor. We mentioned this to the owner, who took my payment and said he would discuss it with the cook. I believe he should have talked to the cook first, and even reviewed the leftovers before taking our money. We're not looking for a free meal or anything like that, but for $22, we would appreciate a more genuine acknowledgment of our dissatisfaction. To top it off, our waitress only returned to our table when we asked for the check; we didn't see her at all during the meal. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.

I love it! It's a large slice of pizza packed with plenty of meat and cheese. The portion size is generous, and I think the price is quite reasonable.

Horrible service and customer service. Ordered cheesecake received soggy cake tasted very similar to key lime pie. Slice was placed upside down and packaged that way. Would never order from them again. Called in to notify staff of my dissatisfactionand was rudely interrupted.

Pretty solid pizza but garlic knots are kinda expensive.