Sicilian Delight Pizza - NEW HARTFORD

I usually don’t have any issues with Sicilian Joy. In fact, their Sicilian pizza is my favorite! However, I was sadly disappointed today when I received my Grubhub order and discovered that my pizza tasted like mold. Please pay more attention to your ingredients in the future, especially regarding how long they’ve been stored or left out. I’m relieved I tried it before my son did, as it could have made him sick.

I had an amazing experience at this restaurant! The pizza is excellent, and the macaroni and meatballs are delicious. The rolls—pepperoni, spinach, and buffalo chicken—are also great, and the chicken fritters are a must-try. This is definitely the best place to eat in the area, and the service is commendable.

I just wanted to say thank you! I lived in New Hartford from 1984-1987 (high school) and this was my favorite pizza. I took a trip to New Hartford yesterday and was so happy to see you are still in Sangertown! I just had to order the Sicilian pizza to take home to my kids. It is just as wonderful as I remember!!! Your staff was so friendly and attentive. Such good food and fond memories!!! Thank you!!!

This place probably serves some of the best pizzas in the area. As you can see from my phone, I had some issues with the delivery. However, the pizza itself is fantastic, especially the tomato pie. Make sure to enjoy it cold—don’t let it sit and warm up!

Her pizza was very hot from the oven. You make pizza right, prepare every pizza with care.