The Pastry Pixie - Neenah

We recently had our wedding cake made by Pastry Pixie and we were thrilled with the results! Many of our guests told us that the cakes were the best they had ever tasted! They delivered the cakes and coordinated seamlessly with our florist, who provided fresh flowers from Sterling Floral in Neenah. They even made a gluten-free cake for our head table. We had individual cakes at each table, and they were extremely accommodating throughout the process. We chose Pastry Pixie because they were one of the few bakeries willing to make 25 cakes for us. I would highly recommend Pastry Pixie!

We ordered a cake for our daughter's 4th birthday, and it was absolutely fantastic! She had a How to Train Your Dragon theme for her party. We brought along some little dragon heads, and they placed them on top of the cake! I also provided a picture of what I had in mind, and while they used icing instead of fondant like in the photo, the cake turned out so close to what I envisioned. My daughter adored the cake, and everyone at the party raved about its beauty. I highly recommend this place!

I visited Pastry Pixie to order a custom cake for my daughter's baby shower, and I was excited to learn that the owner is a Le Cordon Bleu graduate. They truly operate from the ground up! I was encouraged to explore ideas on Pinterest and show them how I envisioned my cake. I decided on a delicious marble cake, and I must say, the frosting was perfect—creamy without being overly rich. The cake was thick, moist, and beautifully layered; it was simply divine! Usually, I'm not a fan of store-bought, heavy buttercream frosting, but their version was outstanding. I was thoroughly impressed! I will definitely return for my next cake. Plus, they offer the best café lunches, and their cupcakes are out of this world!

Inflamed! I ordered several cakes, including gluten-free cakes and cupcakes, for a big weekend. The cakes were beautiful, and all guests had glowing supplements on how great everything tasted. I will order from here again!!

I have been coming since they first opened a few years ago and cannot go anywhere else for a chicken salad sandwich or cupcakes. My family won't even order cakes anywhere else but the Pastry Pixie. So incredibly happy for them in their new endeavors downtown Neenah.