Mattarello Bakery Café - Montclair

Good food but smaller portion size. Please order accordingly.

Imagine it’s your 30th birthday and your birthday cake is ruined by this bakery. They said they were able to recreate a cake similar to my reference pictures. When I saw the cake that I received I wanted to cry so badly. Never in my 30 years of life have I ever seen a cake so horrible! As for the taste taste I ordered strawberry shortcake and it taste like it was months old it was disgusting and gross. I had to dump the entire cake in the trash immediately. Ruined my birthday and I’m so disappointed by this bakery. This bakery is trash!!!! Do not order custom cakes from them unless you want to be disappointed. I wish I could give zero star!

Ordered online for pick up—order was ready on time and staff was excellent. Pastries and desserts were good. The lobster tail was the favorite.

Not only is the coffee great, but the workers there are super friendly, and are very helpful. I come to this coffee shop a few times and I’ve never seen any of them without a smile on their face! They even let me do a photoshoot in there. Amazing place! Wish I could rate it higher.

I’ve bought my last 3 cakes from Mattarello’s and my friends and family always love it! Great tasting and high quality pastries. The shop is always very clean as well.