Pizza Village - MONTAUK

The pizza was just average and not very enjoyable, but the calamari were cooked to perfection.

Convenient location in walking distance to town. pizza is so-so. usually a last option place. rude service, closed the walk-up window on a customer a minute after close. the crowd wasnt pleased. (2) stars for location convenience. (2) stars for pizza.(0) stars for staff/service

I ordered the minestrone soup and it was terrible! It tasted like tomato sauce with some vegetables thrown in—completely lacking in flavor and spices. I don’t usually write reviews, but I’m really disappointed. I'm still hungry, and it feels like I have nothing to eat. I also think $6 for such a small container of tomato sauce is way too much.

The calamari was fresh and cooked perfectly! The homemade marinara sauce was fantastic as well! However, the pizza didn’t meet my expectations, although the toppings were generous. The staff was wonderful and offered great recommendations! We stopped in for a quick bite after visiting the lighthouse. Please note that this place only accepts cash for dine-in, but you can pay by card for online pickup orders.

Pizza Village is the place to go in Montauk for your pizza fix. It's a dated establishment that has been around for a long time. A classic old school pizzeria with tables inside and outside. Very good pizza slices ????, pies and an assortment of Italianfavorites. It's well worth the visit. Enjoy. ???? ????????