Hilltop At Montauk Manor

So much character history plus amazing views I’d recommend a visit, room was large, well appointed and comfy massive bed, dishwasher, coffee machine and microwave really useful Staff were super helpful and friendly, especially the drivers who’ll give you a lift down to the town etc that’s a real asset Only negative is out of season no restaurant or bar left the place feeling a little soulless Tennis pool look great for in the warmer weather and we were offered board games too I’d definitely come back

We really enjoyed dining here. Atmosphere could use some attention. We liked the casual environment but it felt a bit like a college dining room trying to be cool with the garage doors and painted floor. Great food! We enjoyed the brussels sprouts side as an appetizer and the fried cheese. FOS broth was good but there needs to be more cheese on the top (just the little bit of bread in the center had cheese...definitelythe wrong type of bowl for serving). Penne Vodka was perfect and loved the addition of the asparagus. My husband enjoyed his burger. Drinks came out quickly and were good and strong! Our waitress was awesome! And she took care of all the tables on her own!! Kudos to her lovely service with a smile!! If the decor was updated a bit, and a few more options in the $17-$25 bracket added, I feel like this place could be pretty packed on the weekends!

We ate breakfast here and it was so good. The waitress was sweet and attentive. Their breakfast menu is somewhat limited for winter season but that was fine as we were looking for a simple breakfast. We both got egg and cheese croissants. My husband had his with bacon and I had mine with turkey. They were well stuffed and buttery. Sorry for no pics we were hungry ! We stayed here once before, but didn't try it and I'm glad we did this time. It was delish!

We came with a film crew and we received the WARMEST welcome from the entire staff! Donna, Tracy, Patty and Janice are some of the BEST. They went out of their way to make us so welcome and they provided the upmost care to us. The building is beautiful and the rooms are spacious. We just loved it so much!

We had an excellent meal at the Hilltoplast evening. Rockefeller stuffed mushrooms were amazing. Fish was fresh, beautifully presented and deliciously prepared. Staff was friendly and helpful.it was our first visit. We will definitely be back.