Carmella's Pizzeria Middletown - Feedback

The best pizza we've had by far, and we've tried quite a few! The garlic parmesan cheese is a must-try, and the cheerful garlic bread is absolutely delicious!

I absolutely adore everything about this place! From the food to the owner to the staff, everything is просто amazing!

The pizza here is truly incredible! The service is excellent, and the place is spotless. You absolutely have to try the oven-baked French fries—they're out of t...

I never had a bad meal or experience here!!! Just delicious!!

We are new to the area and finding this gem was a pleasant surprise. Hands down the best pizza on Aquidneck Island. The dining area is a bit cramped, but that d...

I've been coming here for two years and have always ordered the spicy shrimp salad, which has consistently been amazing. However, I decided to try something new...

As newcomers to the area, discovering this gem was a delightful surprise. Without a doubt, it's the best pizza on Aquidneck Island. The dining area is somewhat....

Pricy, but totally worth it. The dough and crust are perfectly crispy, chewy, and delicious, while the sauce is fantastic. Even the pepperoni is top-notch!

I haven't had Carmella's in FOREVER, and I had a random craving for the steak and cheese pizza...was scared it had changed or wouldn't be what I...

Best pizza we have had by far and we've tried a lot of pizza! The garlic Parmesan crust is a must and the cheesy garlic bread is delicious!

I visited the area for a week, but the restaurant was never open during the summer. They might as well close for good, or perhaps they already have but haven't...

I've been enjoying the incredible pizza at this place for many years! I highly recommend their white pizzas, like the Buffalo chicken, rosemary chicken, and ste...

I had the worst pizza experience ever, especially as a first-time visitor. The pizza was burnt on the bottom, and I didn't notice until I got home. I'm truly di...

Ordered half olive and mushroom and they charged me for two toppings. I asked and they said they dont do half rudely and walked away? Could have told me on the...

I LOVE YOUR PIZZA

I'm sorry to report that it seems they have permanently closed; their phone is disconnected. It's tough to find a substitute for their amazing pizzas.

This pizza was incredible! The buffalo chicken and chicken bacon ranch flavors were absolutely fantastic.

I must also mention the SNOWTINI, a drink made with various types of vodka and coconut. It's absolutely fantastic, but be warned: it's very sweet! Overall, I ha...