Coney Island Cafe - Feedback

Been coming here for decades!Still, great people friendly staff, good eats!!

Couldn't even put not one star. I ordered breakfast. It was eggs and pancakes the eggs. I said over medium they came overheard. Look like egg salad. The pancake...

Homefries taste like chemicals. Pancakes weren’t cooked all the way and they want to charge $14. Ridiculous stay away from there.

Undercooked eggs and soggy toast, the food wasn't cooked properly and tastes off. They're not that hard to cook correctly so I don't understand what the issue i...

Food was absolutely cold and disgusting bathrooms were disgusting

If you're hungry for anything or sing or you got the munchies this is the place I recommend for anybody. They have breakfast all day long till they close and th...

Recommended by a friend who has been living in Middletown for over 40 years, so we tried their loaded hotdogs. It was good, and I liked the fries too. Very good...

Food was good and fresh. I did uber eats and they didn't make my order until I got there

Staff is friendly. The food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable.

As good as I remember. Coney dogs are one of those nostalgic things I have to have whenever I visit the area. Great service. Staff was friendly and accomodating...

Coney Cheesesteak Combo was very large portion sized, good flavor overall very good. The Philly Dog was okay, priced good and tasty. The Sliced Roast Beef Tripl...

Cheeseburger Combo was perfect season and nice and hot the Bacon Cheese Fries yummy had to fight over them hotdogs were perfect

First time ever ordering here and let me just say.. this place is spectacular! delicious food and without a doubt worth ever penny! thank you so much for this a...

It was delicious! Warm and very very good. Definitely will order again!