Scotto Pizza - Matawan

UPDATE: I’m eating the leftovers now and have to lower my rating by a star. I found black hair baked into the pizza crust. Yikes… it’s making me feel a bit nauseous.

I visited this pizza place for the first time and was blown away by the variety of slices they offer! The staff was friendly and attentive, answering all of our questions. We ordered three slices: we both tried the vodka slice and shared a pepperoni slice with honey, which was my first time tasting something like that. It was incredible! We'll definitely be coming back soon. The prices are reasonable, and there are plenty of options on the menu.

I've been hearing about this place for months! I never visited before because I live in Keyport and don’t come this way often. However, with my kids' busy schedules filled with sports and dance, I’ve ended up here at least once a week! I’ve never been disappointed. The staff is incredibly friendly, and the pizza is exceptional! The regular slice, vodka slice, grandma slice with pesto, and the hot honey pepperoni are all fantastic! Looking forward to coming back on Saturday!

Great food and amazing pizza ! They have amazing customer service as well. I made a mistake and ordered pizza from their other location. They were more than understanding. Highly recommend them to everyone.

Amanda is the best!!!!!! Everytime my girlfriend and I come in she is super nice and recommends all of her favorites that end up being absolutely delicious! We come here atleast 2-3 times a week, and get different things everytime that we end up loving. Love love love this place! And her!