Binnekill Tavern - Margaretville

Total not. has great potential, but missed some points. poor service (expects more than 15 minutes before asking if I wanted a drink), wein must have been from an old vintage bc, it did not taste the art as it has blackened, had to brot with my meal and it is no cheaper place. but what I ordered was good. small portions, but good. that landed, seen, it will not go back.

We enjoyed our dinner. There was enough variety that each of us was able to find a good choice. Dessert was delicious.

The lamb dish I ordered was good, but it was served warm, just like the Butternut Squash soup. I've eaten here many times and this is the first time I've been disappointed. I’ll give it another chance, though.

Nicole was, as always, fantastic. However, the dining experience was not what it used to be. The risotto, priced at $36, was one of the worst I’ve had at a restaurant. It was undercooked, mushy on the outside and hard on the inside. The dish arrived lukewarm at best. I would recommend just ordering the basics, like burgers, and making sure to specify that you want them hot. This was not the first, second, or even third time we received lukewarm food, including soup and fries.

The dining experience and service were outstanding in a warm and inviting atmosphere.