Nicky's Firehouse Italian Pizzeria - Feedback

Hi, I ordered takeout and Sophia took my order and confirmed it back to me. Not just read the list, but she also clarified 3 pizzas and 3 apps. I've made mistak...

The food was absolutely incredible! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful, and service was prompt. My children and I will definitely be returning soon!!

Amazing food, service was great, as was the atmosphere.

It was okey. Slow service for spaghetti and meatballs.

We come here quite often and always enjoy the food and atmosphere. We are always greeted by Pat and other friendly faces. Joe and Amanda have done an amazing jo...

Nicky?s was truly impressive. Their cauliflower crust pizza has wicked flavor, it?s crispy, and it?s gluten free! Wouldn?t have known it was a GF crust. Snagged...

What a wonderful experience!! If you are looking to book a private party Nicky?s Firehouse is your spot! The owners, Joe and Amanda are a pleasure to work with....

This is my go-to spot!! Whatever you want, whether it?s a quick slice or a sit-down dinner with friends and family, Nicky?s is always the smart choice! I try so...

I have been to NICKYS in Madison NJ on 2 occasions. The place is modeled after a fire station and is a very cute building. However, the Italian food is mediocre...

Definitely one of the nest pizza places I have ever been. Great service and everyone was so welcoming. I will definitely be going back again and again. Great fa...