Benny Scarpetta's - Lynchburg

Horrible! Idk what happened to Bennys! I would’ve been better off with a Red Baron Pizza! The cheese was burnt, there was hardly any sauce and it was DRY! Waste of $40 on a pickup including a tip!! Super unsatisfied and even more disappointing to call and not get an answer! THIS NEEDS TO BE RECTIFIED!! ??

Our pizza was overcooked and when we mentioned it, they offered to recook it for us. I decided to eat mine anyway, but my wife had hers recooked because it was awful. Unfortunately, the second slice came out in the same shape as the first and we didn't have time to wait for another recook. It's a shame that they don't have the same quality of employees as they used to, who made some of the best pizza in town. It's just not the same as the good old days.

Bennie's, a former reliable choice for NY style pizza, has now unfortunately declined in quality. The lack of service has become a major issue, making it difficult to enjoy the mediocre food.

Always a nice time to grab a NY style slice of pizza! They don’t have many flavors but they are good at what they do. Typically have the normal cheese, pepperoni, sausage, garlic and mushroom and then they have flavors of the month. You are in and out within minutes. Huge slices! About $6-$8 per person.

I have found a new favorite pizza spot in Lynchburg - this place serves authentic New York style pizza! The slices are huge, with delicious sauce and a perfect crust.