Fat Jack's Pizza Findlay Rd - Lima

Every time I visit my hometown, I make sure to stop by Fat Jack's for pizza! I live in Wilmington, NC, where the predominant pizza style is New York-style. I really wish they would open a Fat Jack's down here to show everyone what REAL PIZZA tastes like!

This is my favorite pizza place. Sometimes they make pizzas that are amazing, while other times they taste as if a three-year-old made them. It's been quite inconsistent lately, but it's still the best in town.

The food at this restaurant is consistently incredible and always surpasses my expectations for a good pizza. Each bite reminds me of the wonderful times spent at my grandparents' house. As someone with dietary restrictions, I’m thrilled to have found this place. Their gluten-free sausage pizza is simply outstanding!

This is a delicious, piping hot, CLASSIC Ohio pizza! For those unfamiliar, Ohio pizza features a relatively thin crust, served piping hot, and is round but cut into squares. It sits perfectly between Detroit and New York styles, making it a true Midwestern delight. Fat Jack's is a prime example of this pizza tradition. The establishment may be older, but it's well maintained, and the cashiers are friendly. When it comes to the pizza, they offer a wide variety of toppings, and you won't have to wait long to enjoy it. While we usually stick to the pizza, they also have sides like cheese bread and wings. JUST GET THERE! Please note that this is a carryout-only location—there’s no seating, as it operates like a party store.

Best pizza period! We come down from Findlay because there is no other pizza that comes close in the area.