The Boxcar Llc - Lilly

Wings that we got was horrible. They was chewy not crunchy and the hot sauce was like water with a little bit of heat and sweet from the honey they was to only drizzle not pour. Hobo fry's was ok nothing to talk about. And the price was way way to much. We will definitely not be back there for the wings. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner

Specializes in Burgers but seems like everything is good there. Family run business, clean, attentive. The food was delicious and reasonably priced. The establishment also has a bar. Will visit again. Overall, Grade A Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5

We have eaten here on several occasions, the food and service has been exceptional every time! Wings are awesome, quesadillas are amazing and the beer is always cold! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I'll start by saying don't judge a book by its cover and I only say that because the outside is very unassuming. The inside of this establishment was clean and roomy. The atmosphere was quiet and relaxing to enjoy a meal. The young lady that greeted us and took us to a table was very friendly and our server Tiffany was awesome, informative and attentive. We found the prices to be very reasonable and the food was amazing. We had a pizza and hobo fries along with a couple beers and our stomachs were definitely full and very satisfied. The pizza was great and the pulled pork with BBQ sauce on the hobo fries was really tasty with a little kick, also the beer was nice and cold. A definite hidden gem which we're glad we stopped at after our motorcycle ride. If your passing through Lilly, PA or just in the area stop in I don't think y'all would be disappointed. We've already made plans to go again!

What a place this has become! I remember going here 25 years ago when it was under a different name and now has become such a cool establishment in the town of Lilly. Trackside to watch trains and the bar is themed with the railroad history. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner