Goodfellas Pizzeria Mill Street

Great pizza...big vibes...small flop. airy crust..worth the stop to fill the search. completely agree with the portnoy scale....7.7

My wife and I dropped into Lexington for a short visit. Our first night was during Lexington 's Thursday Night Live on a closed-off down-town street with live music and food trucks. What do we see? Folks everywhere with Goodfellas Pizza boxes, eating and listening to the music. Told my wife, I want that for dinner tomorrow. Next day we walked to their location. There is limited seating outside, just a couple of tables, but most everyone gets it by the slice to go. (I also noticed Goodfellas makes their own crust. We ordered a 16 pizza. We were told, about 25 minutes so I set the timer on my iPhone, found a nearby bar, the Rosebud, and waited it out. (Downtown Lex is nice like that, plenty of bars . Picked up our pizza, hot and fresh, walked it to our nearby Airbnb and had some great New York style pie. Man it was good, with plenty leftover for breakfast the next morning. If you want pizza in the Lex, this is the place to get it.

Fantastic pizza... I would highly recommend it to anyone! There will be a line and it's there for a reason! If you want the meatball sub, call ahead...

Best pizza EVER! I love pizza, but typically only eat on derby day, it's my ritual. I braved UK graduation traffic to get my Goodfellas from Mill Street. Yes, I know there are more in town, but Mill Street Goodfellas does it the best!

This is the place to go at any time! Awesome pizza. The slices are huge and most of the time, one slice would fill you up. Convenient location to all surrounding clubs. Always a must go after spending times at the clubs. I like how they make the Pizza in front of you and they always have multiple choices of tasty pizza. A must go!